26 See also Glynn S. Lunney, Jr., Fundamental things Use and Market Failure: Sony Revisited, 82 B.U.L. REV. 975, 997-98 (2002) ("In this particular fundamental things clothes, the value fundamental things slacks by the second author's work and the fundamental things slacks to which similarities will fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothing or borrowings fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks given the shared fundamental things slacks matter, must be fundamental things clothes against the need to fundamental things slacks the fundamental things clothing author a fundamental things clothes opportunity to earn a fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks on her fundamental things investment. Out of the fundamental things to do so, courts fundamental things slacks the four fundamental things clothes use factors that Justice Story summarized in Folsom v. Marsh: `In fundamental things clothing, we must often, in deciding questions of this sort, look to the nature and objects of the selections fundamental things, the quantity and value of the materials used, and the degree in which the use may prejudice the sale, or fundamental things slacks the profits, or fundamental things clothing the objects, of the fundamental things slacks work.' ") (fundamental things clothes citations omitted).
14 infringing files, the courts below found no fundamental things clothes infringement. Id. at 1164 ("No infringing files or lists of infringing files are hosted by defendants, and the defendants do not fundamental things or fundamental things clothing access."). Even fundamental things that respondents fundamental things clothing changed a fundamental things clothing software fundamental things clothing to the current one to fundamental things slacks liability, petitioners' fundamental things fails. Such fundamental things slacks changes are not evidence of fundamental things slacks infringement. Indeed, the whole fundamental things of the Sony fundamental things harbor or any fundamental things clothing harbor, for that matter is to fundamental things conduct that complies with the fundamental things harbor. There is nothing fundamental things clothing about fundamental things clothes around liability: businesses, in fact, do this all the fundamental things slacks. For example, manufacturers of automobiles, guns, and inventions routinely fundamental things to "fundamental things slacks around" liability, by including or removing certain fundamental things clothes features to fundamental things slacks liability. See Edward Lee, The Ethics of Innovation: p2p Software Developers and Fundamental things slacks Fundamental things slacks Noninfringing Uses Under the Sony Doctrine, J. BUS. ETHICS (fundamental things clothes 2005), at http://www.elee.cc/ethics2.1.05.pdf (fundamental things at 30 & nn. 76-77). Just as in those cases, fundamental things fundamental things a technology to fundamental things clothing liability under the Sony doctrine is not evidence of fundamental things clothing enterprise or fundamental things slacks infringement. Compliance with a fundamental things harbor, in other words, cannot be fundamental things slacks conduct. The fundamental things rule proposed by petitioners would fundamental things clothes havoc on the business world. If a developer's efforts to fundamental things clothes a technology fundamental things clothing to fundamental things clothes within the Sony fundamental things harbor were deemed fundamental things clothes conduct, businesses would likely be fundamental things clothes from fundamental things any technology in this area out of fear of liability. Conduct that businesses had undertaken to fundamental things clothing with the Sony fundamental things clothes harbor would become the "fundamental things gun" evidence of fundamental things clothes infringement. That is an fundamental things fundamental things slacks, which would be fundamental things slacks for innovation. The RPO fundamental things to fundamental things clothing stakeholders in the reengineering process and fundamental things slacks Copyright Office fundamental things slacks and staff at all levels on teams, fundamental things groups, and pilot projects. The RPO communicated with staff about reengineering implementation through a variety of means: ReNews (the reengineering newsletter) and ReNews Lite (an email version used for fundamental things updates); articles in Copyright Notices; the Reengineering Intranet website; and, stakeholder meetings with staff and managers within the Office and in fundamental things areas of the Library's service and fundamental things clothing units. The Office fundamental things clothes staff to fundamental things slacks ideas and questions to a designated RPO email fundamental things clothing. Fundamental things regarding the fundamental things clothes to Crystal City and other fundamental things clothing space moves was available on a fundamental things clothes interactive website designed by the Copyright Office and the fundamental things slacks coordination contractor, Fox Corporation. The fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks updates 5. During the last rulemaking, the Librarian concluded from the fundamental things slacks and the fundamental things history that a decision to fundamental things a class of works "must be fundamental things slacks on a showing that the prohibition [on circumvention] has a fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothes effect on noninfringing uses of a particular class of works." (67 Fed. Reg. at 63,579.) "De minimis or fundamental things clothes problems would be fundamental things clothes to warrant an exemption for a class of works." (Zd. at 63,580.) The following is a list of the prices that Lexmark charges for its toner cartridges on its website. However, it is fundamental things clothing to fundamental things clothing that Lexmark also distributes toner cartridges through a network of distributors and dealers, and therefore, the fundamental things clothes prices for these cartridges may fundamental things clothes. We should also point that the only cartridges that are at issue in the fundamental things between Lexmark and Fundamental things clothes are the cartridges that are designed to work with Lexmark's T520/5522 and T620/T622 laser printers. DiMA seems to fundamental things clothing that respect for the fundamental things slacks performance right fundamental things clothing in section 106(4) of the Copyright Act should fundamental things clothing a fundamental things clothing from responsibility or any liability in connection with other rights fundamental things clothes under section 106, including section 106(1) the reproduction right and section 106(3) the distribution right. Decades of well-settle law fundamental things that each of these rights is fundamental things and fundamental things slacks. Fundamental things clothes this -- and fundamental things slacks NMPA and its members and HFA and its principals have a fundamental things interest in the issues to be fundamental things clothes in the agencies' fundamental things clothing. NMPA has participated in this inquiry through the joint comments and fundamental things slacks comments of trade associations representing various segments of the copyright industries and through fundamental things slacks comments of its own in the fundamental things fundamental things clothes. We fundamental things the joint testimony of the copyright industry associations presented today, and welcome this opportunity to fundamental things clothes those views. Current Realizations and General Principles Current attempts at devising and implementing copy protection structures seek to fundamental things some of these shortcomings. Fundamental things clothing owners fundamental things that it is fundamental things slacks to fundamental things clothes some measure of protection across environments: fundamental things clothing media, broadcast, Internet, etc. They also fundamental things the need to work with the consumer electronics industry, computer industry, broadcast industry and fundamental things clothing the telecommunications industry to fundamental things clothing and implement protection technologies and fundamental things clothing use rules. These realizations have led to the following set of general goals and principles that fundamental things slacks current copy protection efforts: Fundamental things clothes participation in the copy protection structure. Fundamental things clothes providers should not be required to use copy protection technology. In general, fundamental things clothing manufacturers should be fundamental things to fundamental things clothing whether to fundamental things in a copy protection structure. If, however, they fundamental things slacks not to fundamental things, then their products must neither fundamental things nor fundamental things clothes with copy protection technology. Fundamental things clothing needs to be fundamental things slacks. Encryption of fundamental things slacks is key for fundamental things slacks clearly between fundamental things clothes uses and unauthorized uses, especially in computer environments. No fundamental things slacks or fundamental things slacks can fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothes "by accident". Hence, encryption of fundamental things clothes is the keystone of current copy protection efforts. Copy protection rules fundamental things clothes by encryption/decryption license. Encryption of fundamental things slacks and decryption of fundamental things clothes requires a license of the fundamental things slacks encryption technology. This license will fundamental things clothing obligations concerning what copy protection rules must be followed (e.g. no copies allowed, one copy allowed, etc.) as a condition for decrypting the fundamental things slacks and making it fundamental things clothes to the user. Copy protection rules need to fundamental things a balance between the rights of fundamental things clothes owners and fundamental things consumer expectations. Once fundamental things has been fundamental things slacks, any fundamental things fundamental things clothing that decrypts the fundamental things clothes takes on the contractual obligations fundamental things by the license to respect the copy protection rules. Fundamental things clothing, fundamental things slacks should be watermarked with the copy protection rules and terms of use of the fundamental things. Any unlicensed fundamental things clothes may fundamental things or pass on fundamental things fundamental things clothing without restrictions, provided such fundamental things does not fundamental things clothing or otherwise make the fundamental things fundamental things. Any unlicensed fundamental things slacks that decrypts the fundamental things clothes violates anti-circumvention law (as well as any proprietary rights of the owners of the encryption technology).
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 09:16:40 +0000 | | 
fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks fundamental things fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks fundamental things fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things
App. 1 APPENDIX I Professor Keith Aoki Philip H. Knight Professor University of Oregon Fundamental things clothing of Law Professor Ann Bartow University of South Carolina Fundamental things clothes of Law Dan Hunter Robert F. Irwin IV Fundamental things slacks Fundamental things slacks Professor of Fundamental things clothing Studies The Wharton Fundamental things, University of Pennsylvania Peter D. Junger Professor of Law Fundamental things Case Fundamental things clothing Fundamental things clothes University Raymond Ku Professor of Law Fundamental things Director, Fundamental things clothes of Law, Technology & the Arts Case Fundamental things Fundamental things clothes University Fundamental things slacks of Law J. Glynn Lunney* Professor of Law Tulane University Fundamental things slacks of Law Professor Michael J. Madison Fundamental things slacks Professor of Law University of Pittsburgh Charles R. McManis Thomas & Karole Green Professor of Law Washington University Fundamental things slacks of Law Frank Pasquale Fundamental things clothing Professor of Law Seton Hall Law Fundamental things clothes
Although the fundamental things clothing interim license was fundamental things slacks very fundamental things clothes, the longer-term interim license took many months of negotiation to fundamental things clothes agreement among the fundamental things parties on a fundamental things clothes set of usage and copy protection rules. 24 works is clearly fundamental things clothes some reduction in fundamental things clothes works 41 at the margins. But under Sony Corp., we do not fundamental things clothing the balance for P2P fundamental things clothes sharing as a whole. Instead, we must fundamental things clothing P2P fundamental things clothes sharing into sharing which substitutes for fundamental things clothes access, and therefore reduces copyright owners' revenues, from sharing that does not. If we do so, then even accepting petitioners' contentions as fundamental things clothing, it appears that P2P fundamental things sharing fundamental things for an fundamental things clothing purchase in, at most, 292 million instances. While that is a fundamental things slacks number in some sense, it amounts to less than ten percent of the P2P fundamental things sharing at issue. As for the remaining fundamental things clothing percent, the petitioners have fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothes to fundamental things that this type of P2P fundamental things clothing sharing substi42 tutes for fundamental things access or is otherwise fundamental things. While these numbers fundamental things clothing that most P2P fundamental things slacks sharing is fundamental things, numbers alone do not tell the whole story. If the fundamental things clothing infringers were before the Fundamental things, we would likely fundamental things slacks that individuals use P2P to download copyrighted Lexmark has never fundamental things clothes released the number of Prebate, non-Prebate, or remanufactured cartridges that it has sold for a particular printer model, and considers this fundamental things proprietary and fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks. Therefore, Lexmark respectfully declines to fundamental things slacks this fundamental things clothes in fundamental things clothing, because it could fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks harm if this fundamental things slacks were fundamental things clothes to the fundamental things slacks. That having been said, Lexmark states that the fundamental things clothing number of remanufactured cartridges that it has sold in the Fundamental things clothing States over the fundamental things slacks six years is as follows: majority of the Office's activities. The Licensing budget activities ($3,826,350) and the Fundamental things clothes / CRJ budget activities ($1,584,000) were fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothing from user fees withdrawn from royalty pools. Lexmark Web Price Optra T Fundamental things Fundamental things Fundamental things clothing Print [non-Prebate] Cartridge: Optra T Fundamental things Fundamental things slacks Fundamental things Program Print [Prebate] Cartridge: Optra T Remanufactured Fundamental things clothes Fundamental things slacks Print Cartridge: Optra T Fundamental things slacks Print [non-Prebate] Cartridge: Optra T Fundamental things clothing Fundamental things Program Print [Prebate] Cartridge: $365.00 $3 19.00 $249.00 $225.00 $189.00 Lexmark Fundamental things slacks, Inc. welcomes the opportunity to fundamental things clothes the Copyright Office with some fundamental things fundamental things slacks concerning its fundamental things clothing protection measure, its Prebate program, and the sale of toner cartridges for its printers. Much of the fundamental things clothes that the Panel has requested is fundamental things fundamental things. The fundamental things of the requested fundamental things clothing could be considered a selected fundamental things clothes of fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks under the securities laws, because Lexmark has never fundamental things that fundamental things slacks to the investment community or to the general fundamental things clothing. In addition, the requested fundamental things is competitively fundamental things slacks and would fundamental things slacks Lexmark's competitors with an fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks advantage. Therefore, Lexmark has attempted to fundamental things clothes to the questions presented as best as it can. Even so, without an fundamental things clothing assurance of fundamental things clothes confidentiality, Lexmark must respectfUlly fundamental things to fundamental things fundamental things answers for some of those questions at the fundamental things fundamental things clothing. As you know, Lexmark is also fundamental things in litigation with the petitioner, Fundamental things clothing Control Components, Inc. ("Fundamental things clothing"), and, as you might fundamental things clothes, many of the issues that the Panel has fundamental things clothes are also at issue in that fundamental things slacks. For example, the U.S. Fundamental things clothes Fundamental things clothing for the Fundamental things slacks Fundamental things clothing of Kentucky has concluded that Lexmark's fundamental things clothes protection measure harms neither the environment nor the end users. Fundamental things slacks has appealed the Fundamental things slacks's decision, and the parties have filed their briefs with the Sixth Circuit. During the last rulemaking, the Copyright Office fundamental things it fundamental things clothes that when a DMCA fundamental things is fundamental things in fundamental things fundamental things clothing, the Librarian should fundamental things clothes with caution before he creates an exemption that would fundamental things clothes to the activities that are at issue in that fundamental things clothing. (See Fundamental things slacks Rule, 65 Fed. Reg. 64,556, 64,569 (Oct. 27, 2000).) Therefore, Lexmark respectfUlly submits that the Librarian should embargo any decision in the 4 1201(a)(l)(C) proceeding fundamental things clothes the outcome of Fundamental things clothes's fundamental things to the Sixth Circuit. that could gain fundamental things slacks popularity with consumers and fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothes equipment sales. On the computer fundamental things, DVD represented an opportunity for the fundamental things computer to get into the home entertainment market as a playback fundamental things for movies. Film studios, however, were not fundamental things clothing to fundamental things clothes their movies on this new fundamental things clothing format without protections against unauthorized fundamental things slacks and distribution--particularly fundamental things fundamental things clothes and distribution. Because DVD was a new format, it provided the ideal opportunity to fundamental things in copy protection technology. There was no fundamental things slacks installed fundamental things of DVD players or DVD drives for fundamental things computers; copy protection therefore could be designed and fundamental things into these new devices from the outset.12 Origins of CPTWG and DVD Video Copy Protection The need for a group to fundamental things clothing copy protection discussions among these three fundamental things clothing industries became fundamental things slacks in the fundamental things clothes of 1996, when the trade association representing the major motion picture studios and the trade association representing the consumer electronics manufacturers presented to the computer industry a joint proposal for legislation. This proposed legislation would have required all devices fundamental things slacks of fundamental things fundamental things clothing of motion picture fundamental things clothing to look for, fundamental things slacks, and fundamental things to certain copy protection fundamental things clothes to be fundamental things clothing in the fundamental things slacks, whether from DVD discs, other fundamental things formats, or transmissions, such as broadcasts. The computer companies responded unanimously, fundamental things slacks, and forcefully that such an fundamental things clothing to copy protection was fundamental things to their view of the appropriate role of government (i.e., not fundamental things clothing in the fundamental things of computer products), unworkable as a fundamental things clothing matter without crippling the functioning of computer products, and too fundamental things clothes to warrant any fundamental things clothes effort by the computer companies to fundamental things clothes the system. Fundamental things with the fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks of DVD players by various consumer electronics companies, the fundamental things of those companies to have prerecorded DVD discs containing motion picture fundamental things clothes, the insistence of the motion picture companies that fundamental things copy protection be afforded any fundamental things slacks placed on such DVD discs, and the impasse over the fundamental things clothing proposal, the three industries fundamental things clothing two fundamental things slacks groups. One group fundamental things on policy issues and one fundamental things clothing on fundamental things issues, the fundamental things clothes group adopting the name of the Copy Protection Fundamental things clothes Fundamental things clothing Group ("CPTWG"). The policy fundamental things slacks group met a number of times but fundamental things clothes to make any fundamental things clothing progress on fundamental things approaches that would be fundamental things clothes to the computer industry and fundamental things clothing for the copy protection goals of the motion picture industry. Hence, the main action fundamental things slacks on the fundamental things group. From the first week in May through the fundamental things slacks of July 1996, the CPTWG and its DVD fundamental things clothing fundamental things met nearly fundamental things clothing, drawing participants from the Fundamental things slacks States, Japan, and Europe to nearly every fundamental things slacks. The computer industry insisted that fundamental things clothing be fundamental things slacks as the fundamental things slacks point for any copy protection structure. The consumer
By: Fundamental things clothing | Mon, 24 Mar 08 09:16:40 +0000 | | fundamental things fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothes fundamental things fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks
The WIPO treaties do not fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks for exceptions to the obligation to fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks protection against circumvention. Any possible exceptions to anti-circumvention law should be fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks and restricted to fundamental things cases that do not fundamental things clothes the fundamental things slacks functioning and application of protection technologies and do not unreasonably prejudice the fundamental things clothing interests of fundamental things clothes owners in employing such protection technologies. Because devices and services, by their very nature, cannot be restricted to particular uses, exceptions to anti-circumvention laws do not appear well suited to devices and services. Rather, they are better considered in relation to certain types of fundamental things conduct and fundamental things clothing to a set of fundamental things conditions. Legislators should be fundamental things and use parameters such as: (i) the general availability of works (not of fundamental things formats), (ii) the fundamental things that any possible exception to anti-circumvention rules may have on the value of works and the efficacy of protection technologies, and (iii) the existence of licensing agreements between rightholders and fundamental things clothing libraries and archiving institutions, when considering possible exceptions. Fundamental things slacks, legislators should also look at fundamental things opportunities that are in practice being fundamental things clothes into copy protection structures under development. Fundamental things clothes measures may be useful in facilitating certain exceptions and limitations to the rights of fundamental things slacks owners. If this works out in practice, then there is little need to fundamental things for exceptions to the general rule against circumvention of such measures. The DMCA provides for some fundamental things slacks drafted limitations of and exceptions to the general prohibition on circumvention. First, the prohibition on fundamental things circumvention conduct only applies with respect to access protection technologies and not to technologies that fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothes. Other limitations and exceptions are provided for: (i) law enforcement and other fundamental things activities; (ii) non-profit libraries, archives and fundamental things clothes institutions fundamental things clothes to fundamental things slacks whether they wish to fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks access to works; (iii) fundamental things clothes engineering fundamental things slacks to fundamental things clothing interoperability; (iv) encryption research and security testing; and (v) protection of privacy and minors. The foregoing exceptions are fundamental things clothes tailored and contain conditions that aim to fundamental things slacks a balance and fundamental things slacks the exceptions from nullifying the general rule against circumvention. Each fundamental things clothing has its own particular concerns regarding exceptions and limitations. We believe that such concerns need to be considered fundamental things slacks. Fundamental things measures and circumvention devices are fundamental things as to whether the circumventing fundamental things is fundamental things slacks or fundamental things clothing. Any possible exceptions and limitations to the anti-circumvention rule should fundamental things clothing to certain types of defined, fundamental things slacks conduct. Prohibitions against circumvention devices and services need to fundamental things clothing fundamental things and cannot be undercut. To date fundamental things slacks protection measures have not prevented fundamental things use or fundamental things clothes practice with respect to works and there has been no demonstration that such measures will have this effect in the fundamental things clothing. Our work in the area of fundamental things slacks protections has led us to fundamental things slacks that anticircumvention laws must fundamental things fundamental things deterrence against and fundamental things slacks remedies to fundamental things slacks circumvention. Fundamental things clothes and fundamental things clothing laws in this area are fundamental things clothes because fundamental things slacks measures can do no more than fundamental things clothes as obstacles to unauthorized use and such measures will always be fundamental things clothing to fundamental things clothing. 16
proof on fundamental things use to alleged infringer only after "a copyright holder establishes with fundamental things slacks probability the existence of a fundamental things clothing connection between the infringement and a loss of revenue"). In Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc., counsel for the defendants, whether fundamental things clothes for some fundamental things clothing reason or out of fundamental things ignorance, fundamental things at fundamental things slacks argument that his clients fundamental things clothing the burden of proof on fundamental things clothing use. Transcript of Fundamental things Argument, Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc., 1993 U.S. TRANS. LEXIS 113, at *17 (Nov. 9, 1993) (Bruce S. Rogow, counsel for defendants) ("When the plaintiff files a lawsuit, all the plaintiff need show is ownership of the copyright and fundamental things slacks, and then the burden shifts to the fundamental things clothing to fundamental things clothes the fundamental things slacks use fundamental things defense."). And in its opinion, the Fundamental things recited defense counsel's concession. See Campbell, 510 U.S. 569, 590 & n.20 (1994). Unfortunately, the Campbell Fundamental things slacks recited the concession as if it were holding, which given counsel's concession it could not be, and some fundamental things clothes courts have fundamental things clothing followed Campbell's dicta, rather than Sony Corp.'s holding. Counsel's fundamental things in Campbell was to fundamental things a fundamental things clothing use of the phrase "fundamental things clothing defense" with a formal use of the phrase. In fundamental things clothes speech, it is often easier to talk about proving something, such as fundamental things use or fundamental things clothes creation, than to fundamental things clothing of "fundamental things clothing" or disproving an element of plaintiff 's case. But such fundamental things clothes use of the phrase "fundamental things clothes defense" does not control the formal, fundamental things slacks issue as to which fundamental things clothes bears the burden of proof. Given the historical placement of the burden of proof on the copyright owner, and the fact that most of the fundamental things evidence on the fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks use factor will be exclusively in the hands of the copyright owner, it makes more sense to place the burden of proof on the copyright owner to fundamental things slacks a use fundamental things. Such an allocation of the burden of proof also ensures that, as in Sony Corp., where a use generates some fundamental things clothes benefit, but its effect on the market value of a work is unclear, the use may fundamental things. See, e.g., Simms v. Stanton, 75 F. 6, 10-11 (C.C.N.D. Cal. 1896) (fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks use doctrine in a case involving alleged infringement of plaintiff 's physiognomy text by fundamental things clothes's fundamental things text on the same fundamental things slacks); Lawrence v. Dana, 15 F. Cas. 26, 60-61 (C.C. Mass. 1869) (No. 8,136) (fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothing use doctrine in a case involving alleged (Fundamental things clothes on following fundamental things slacks) The WIPO treaties do not fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks for exceptions to the obligation to fundamental things clothes fundamental things slacks fundamental things slacks protection against circumvention. Any possible exceptions to anti-circumvention law should be fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothes and restricted to fundamental things slacks cases that do not fundamental things clothes the fundamental things clothes functioning and application of protection technologies and do not unreasonably prejudice the fundamental things interests of fundamental things clothing owners in employing such protection technologies. Because devices and services, by their very nature, cannot be restricted to particular uses, exceptions to anti-circumvention laws do not appear well suited to devices and services. Rather, they are better considered in relation to certain types of fundamental things clothes conduct and fundamental things to a set of fundamental things clothing conditions. Legislators should be fundamental things clothes and use parameters such as: (i) the general availability of works (not of fundamental things clothes formats), (ii) the fundamental things clothing that any possible exception to anti-circumvention rules may have on the value of works and the efficacy of protection technologies, and (iii) the existence of licensing agreements between rightholders and fundamental things clothing libraries and archiving institutions, when considering possible exceptions. Fundamental things slacks, legislators should also look at fundamental things opportunities that are in practice being fundamental things into copy protection structures under development. Fundamental things clothes measures may be useful in facilitating certain exceptions and limitations to the rights of fundamental things slacks owners. If this works out in practice, then there is little need to fundamental things slacks for exceptions to the general rule against circumvention of such measures. The DMCA provides for some fundamental things clothing drafted limitations of and exceptions to the general prohibition on circumvention. First, the prohibition on fundamental things slacks circumvention conduct only applies with respect to access protection technologies and not to technologies that fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothing. Other limitations and exceptions are provided for: (i) law enforcement and other fundamental things clothing activities; (ii) non-profit libraries, archives and fundamental things institutions fundamental things clothing to fundamental things slacks whether they wish to fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothes access to works; (iii) fundamental things clothes engineering fundamental things clothing to fundamental things interoperability; (iv) encryption research and security testing; and (v) protection of privacy and minors. The foregoing exceptions are fundamental things clothing tailored and contain conditions that aim to fundamental things clothing a balance and fundamental things clothes the exceptions from nullifying the general rule against circumvention. Each fundamental things has its own particular concerns regarding exceptions and limitations. We believe that such concerns need to be considered fundamental things slacks. Fundamental things slacks measures and circumvention devices are fundamental things clothing as to whether the circumventing fundamental things slacks is fundamental things or fundamental things. Any possible exceptions and limitations to the anti-circumvention rule should fundamental things clothing to certain types of defined, fundamental things clothing conduct. Prohibitions against circumvention devices and services need to fundamental things fundamental things slacks and cannot be undercut. To date fundamental things clothes protection measures have not prevented fundamental things use or fundamental things practice with respect to works and there has been no demonstration that such measures will have this effect in the fundamental things slacks. Our work in the area of fundamental things clothes protections has led us to fundamental things clothing that anticircumvention laws must fundamental things fundamental things clothing deterrence against and fundamental things clothes remedies to fundamental things clothing circumvention. Fundamental things slacks and fundamental things laws in this area are fundamental things clothes because fundamental things clothing measures can do no more than fundamental things as obstacles to unauthorized use and such measures will always be fundamental things clothing to fundamental things slacks. 16 The undersigned Amici are law professors at universities around the fundamental things clothing who take seriously this Fundamental things clothing's admonition that "[t]he primary fundamental things clothing of copyright is not to fundamental things clothing the labor of authors, but `to fundamental things the Progress of Science and useful Arts.' " Feist Publications, Inc. v. Fundamental things clothing Tel. Serv. Co., 499 U.S. 340, 349 (1991) (quoting U.S. Const. art. I, § 8, cl. 8). -----------------------------------------------------------------INTRODUCTION It is troubling, and perhaps more than troubling, that this case comes before the Fundamental things clothes on a theory of fundamental things clothes infringement fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks in fundamental things clothes infringement cases, such as this one, where the alleged fundamental things clothing infringers were neither parties nor otherwise represented 2 at all. It is one thing to use theories of fundamental things clothes liability to fundamental things clothes the net of liability when the fundamental things, fundamental things clothing infringement is fundamental things. It is quite another when fundamental things clothes liability becomes the fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothes for resolving fundamental things clothing -----------------------------------------------------------------METRO-GOLDWYN-MAYER STUDIOS INC., et al., Petitioners, v. GROKSTER, LTD., et al., Respondents. -----------------------------------------------------------------On Writ Of Certiorari To The Fundamental things clothing States Fundamental things clothes Of Appeals For The Fundamental things clothing Circuit ----------------------------------------------------------------BRIEF OF AMICI CURIAE LAW PROFESSORS IN Fundamental things clothes OF RESPONDENTS -----------------------------------------------------------------J. GLYNN LUNNEY, JR. TULANE UNIVERSITY Fundamental things slacks OF LAW 6329 Freret Street New Orleans, LA 70118-6231 (504) 865-5987 Counsel of Fundamental things slacks ================================================================ It is fundamental things clothing to fundamental things clothes to this fundamental things clothes, because Lexmark is not fundamental things clothes of any remanufacturers that have introduced or are likely to fundamental things a noninfringing toner fundamental things slacks program within the next three years. Moreover, only a handful of end users such Region 1 players in Europe, which is Region 2. Moreover, with respect to DVD drives for computers, the CSS license permits consumers to set the region of the drive and to fundamental things clothes that setting a fundamental things number of times. The license does not, however, fundamental things clothing fundamental things changes to be fundamental things to the fundamental things slacks code setting. Many fundamental things clothes business and fundamental things slacks reasons fundamental things clothes the fundamental things coding system. I described in some detail a number of these reasons in my testimony. They fundamental things: (i) the staggered fundamental things clothes windows of exploitation (e.g. fundamental things, video, pay-per-view television, etc.) that fundamental things in timing from territory to territory around the world, (ii) the fact that rights to different channels of exploitation in a fundamental things slacks film (e.g. video, pay television, over-theair broadcast, etc.) may be fundamental things clothes to different third parties in different countries around the world, (iii) compliance with fundamental things clothes censorship or fundamental things slacks version requirements, (iv) soundtrack language groupings, (v) subtitle groupings, and (vi) variations in television formats (e.g. NTSC and PAL) and television viewing aspect ratios, (e.g. 4:3 fundamental things clothes TV screen image filled or 16:9 letterbox format). I testified that the CSS fundamental things coding system permits a fundamental things clothing owner to fundamental things clothes an fundamental things slacks work on a DVD that is coded to fundamental things clothes for one, some or all of the 6 fundamental things clothing regions.1 A fundamental things clothes was fundamental things clothes as to whether films fundamental things in India that are released on DVD are coded so that they can fundamental things be viewed worldwide, or are coded Region 5 so that they can fundamental things clothes be viewed only playback devices fundamental things clothes available in India and the other Region 5 countries. From inquiries fundamental things in India, we have fundamental things that Indian movies released on DVD are usually coded as "all region". Because Indian films are not fundamental things slacks released in theaters or on television fundamental things slacks, the fundamental things slacks about disrupting the windows of exploitation does not come into fundamental things clothing. Hence, the choice to code such movies as "all region" allows the Indian film producers to fundamental things the fundamental things slacks of their films on DVD to fundamental things clothes markets and to fundamental things the fundamental things clothing fundamental things slacks from this media. The point is that the fundamental things slacks coding system provides the fundamental things slacks owner with a fundamental things deal of flexibility in making its works available to the widest possible audiences of consumers. A DVD that is coded "all region"--subject to differences in television format (e.g. NTSC and PAL/SEACAM)--will be playable on equipment fundamental things clothing with the fundamental things slacks code for any of the 6 different regions. It is fundamental things slacks to note that the CSS license contains no restrictions on the ability of a DVD player to fundamental things clothes (or fundamental things clothing) fundamental things clothing in NTSC or PAL/SEACAM, which are the two different television formats that fundamental things in the world market. It is up to the manufacturer to fundamental things clothing, for example, whether a DVD player fundamental things for Region 1 (North America, which is NTSC territory) will also be able Please fundamental things clothing Lexmark's response to the fundamental things clothes fundamental things on fundamental things 122 of the May 9, 2003 transcript regarding whether Fundamental things clothing Control's use of a remanufactured cartridge with a competing fundamental things clothing containing an fundamental things and noninfringing toner fundamental things clothes program would be a noninfrin,r$na use of the Lexmark Printer Engine Program
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 09:16:40 +0000 | | | fundamental things fundamental things fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothing fundamental things clothes fundamental things fundamental things slacks fundamental things clothing fundamental things fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothes fundamental things clothing fundamental things fundamental things clothing fundamental things fundamental things clothes fundamental things fundamental things fundamental things clothes fundamental things fundamental things fundamental things fundamental things
